Friday, June 24, 2011

Statements of Animal Rights, Cloning, Among Many Others - and all in one artwork

     Let me take you back for a moment to my college days.  Yes, they seem so long ago... a whopping 4 years now.  Oh how time flies.  So... imagine yourself now - you're sitting next to me in my Environmental Philosophy class behind some random chick that thinks she knows everything about being good to the environment because she keeps all of her slivers of bar soap and puts them in an 'onion bag' so they can be used to completion.  No... I can't make this shit up.  The entire class is in the middle of a heated debate on the rights of beings that can't actually speak for themselves.
     "So, just because something doesn't have a soul - as deemed by your religion, that immediately means it shouldn't have the rights of humans?"  One girl snaps at a boy sitting across the room (he's a religion major).  He doesn't retaliate - he just takes the abuse.
     "But, how far do we take this?  Would we be considered monstrous murderers if we step on an ant, swat a fly, or squash a spider?"  I just sort of wonder aloud.  I'm notorious for doing that with nothing to back it up with. No one really says anything and I feel kind of dumb - but at least no one was countering.  I just hate confrontations.
     "Well, what do we think of Miss Bates's statement?"  My professor inquires.  Oh come on, don't instigate them to argue with me!
     "Well, she has a point.  When do we stop giving rights to everything?  Are we supposed to not trim a tree's branches or move a rock because they both have rights?"

       So you can imagine that this goes on forever with useless banter back and forth because, let's face it, we all love to argue - and most of us love to be heard.
     And what does all of this have to do with my art post for the day?  Let me introduce you to Patricia Piccinini.  She is an Australian artist that uses her skills to make amazing statements.  Some people believe that her imagery is too graphic and too disturbing (my husband is really freaked out by her work), but I, for one, find it very eye-opening and very philosophical.  
     In short, Piccinini creates her artwork to stimulate the thought:  What does it mean to be human?  She has a way of combining animals with the human figure in a way that makes the creatures seem to really exist - leaving us to question:  are we really that different from the animal world?  Below are two of my favorite works of hers from her "We Are Family" series.  I have also inserted some quotes from various sources to describe said artworks because, frankly, they say it better than me.  This artwork is so philosophical, so mind-boggling, that I am having a hard time coming up with the words to explain how I feel. 

Young Family
The following is a statement by User:Patriciapiccinini
from http://en.wikipedia.org
Patricia Piccinini. The Young Family, 2003.

"The Young Family (2002-3) presents a transgenic creature. The inspiration behind this work is the expectation that we have of growing human organs in other species, especially pigs. Rather than make a didactic image that argues for or against these technologies, I want to address the reality of these possible creatures in a very compassionate way. The question I raise, that I am interested in, relates to the distinction between human and animal characteristics: Not so much her humanity, but the 'animalness' in us. Genetically, we share traits with her, but also we share the fundamental trait of looking after offspring. I am interested in the kinds of ways that we look at the many ethical issues that surround medical technologies. There are two kinds of people who are thinking about these issues; those who are objective observers, and those that are actually affected by the issues, such as somebody who has a family member who is affected by a disease. These two viewpoints are often very different. It is impossible to be objective about these issues when you are emotionally involved, but I don't think that is a bad thing. These are not simple issues with easy answers: It is one thing to talk about an idea and another to be confronted by the emotional reality of a creature, and yet another to be in need of what that creature might provide." 

Game Boys Advanced, 2002
 Game Boys Advanced 
From http://www.c-artsmag.com
Statement by: Agung Hujatnikajennong

"Here, Patricia’s visual traits result in an interesting interaction between the work and visitors. Leaning nicely against the entrance wall, the work, at first glance, would seem to be just two normal boys playing a game console, which could be a normal scene even in a museum context these days. Visitors who are not familiar with the work would often just pass them, before noticing that they are actually part of the show. Looking at them more closely, they may then observe that the boys are actually identically cloned and prematurely aged. At the next stage, they may try to touch or grab the human sculptures, as the wrinkled, slack skin on the face and hands looks so unbearably real."

     One thing that I do want to mention about this piece that wasn't discussed in the above statement is that these boys' names were Ollie and Solly.  Now, the symbolism of all of this is that this is referring (in theory) to Dolly - the cloned sheep.  Dolly also prematurely aged at a rapid rate, which some suggest was the reason behind her early death.  It's chilling to think that this, too, would be the fate of these 'boys.'

If you find her work fascinating, intriguing, or you just want to read more, I suggest reading the essay by Linda Michael at the link below.  Personally, I would've loved to have quoted some of what that author had concluded, but the document was copyright and I couldn't paste it here.  I really do hope that you read more about Patricia Piccinini and her artwork.  The article is a great read and is extremely insightful.

Link:  http://www.patriciapiccinini.net/wearefamily/?sec=info#info
Click on the link at the top of the page to go to the PDF file.

Do let me know what you think of her work.  I'm curious to hear what my readers have to say :)

No comments:

Post a Comment